By David Isaac
(JNS) — The demonstrations against Benjamin Netanyahu are back, this time wrapped in calls for the release of the hostages held by Hamas.
Analysts tell JNS that protest organizers, many of whom, like former Prime Minister Ehud Barak, were behind the anti-judicial reform protests, are obsessed with bringing down the Netanyahu government to the exclusion of all else, endangering the war effort and the possibility of a hostage deal.
Since the start of the war, anti-government protests had quieted, only to burst out fiercely in Tel Aviv on Saturday night. Tens of thousands turned out, according to estimates, with protesters blocking the Ayalon Highway and accusing the country’s leadership of purposefully torpedoing a hostage deal.
Some hostages’ families, who joined the protests on Saturday, urged War Cabinet members Benny Gantz and Gadi Eizenkot of the National Unity Party to leave the government and “replace Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu immediately.”
Demonstrations shifted to Jerusalem on Sunday, turning violent on Tuesday night as a group, some bearing torches, evaded barricades and rushed Netanyahu’s official residence.
Police said the protest descended into “unrestrained disorder and street rioting” as “hundreds of rioters tried to break through by force the police barriers placed near the Prime Minister’s Residence.”
Some observers described speeches at the protest as “incitement.” Einav Zangauker, whose son Matan is held by Hamas, said of Netanyahu: “You are the traitor. You betrayed your people. You betrayed your voters. You betrayed the State of Israel.”
She labeled him a “Pharaoh who inflicts on us the plague of the firstborn.”
Efraim Inbar, president of the Jerusalem Institute for Strategy and Security, told JNS that while he has sympathy for the families of hostages, the protests are not helping.
For one thing, it splits the hostages’ families, Inbar said, noting that “not all are against Netanyahu or the Likud Party.”
The Prime Minister’s Office explained that Hamas refused to compromise on its extreme positions, still insisting on “an immediate end to the war, a complete withdrawal of the IDF from the Gaza Strip and leaving its governance capabilities in place to enable it to repeat the massacre of October 7 again and again, as it had promised to do.”
“Basically, it’s not up to Netanyahu to decide whether to free the hostages. Hamas demands an end to the war, which is something to which most Israelis are opposed,” Inbar said.
“The demand that everything should be done to release the hostages is not wise and it’s not even according to the Jewish tradition,” he added.
The activists hope to create rifts within the government coalition, to promote infighting. “They’re even appealing to religious Zionist elements, whom they only recently demonized as extremists, to join them against the ultra-Orthodox for refusing to serve,” Avivi said.
Moshe Feiglin, leader of the Zehut Party and himself an organizer of mass demonstrations, first against the Oslo Accords in the 1990s and later in 2005 against the disengagement from the Gaza Strip, said that the current protests are driven by two things: foreign money and progressive ideology. “It’s a combination of those two forces,” he told JNS.
International money, mainly from Germany and the U.S. — “at least the progressive part of the U.S.” — and funneled through all kinds of NGOs is essentially directed towards “the destruction of the State of Israel.
“It’s state money that funds all this craziness,” said Feiglin. “It’s simply motivated by old antisemitism.”
Secondly, the foot soldiers, the ones out marching in the protests, are what he calls “useful idiots,” those soaked in progressive ideology, which has erased the concept of identity, whether family identity, sexual identity, or even human identity — the idea that there are distinctions between humans and animals. All that’s left is individual identity, he said, and so all that matters is relieving the individual pain of those held hostage by Hamas.
This sort of thinking led to the release of captured IDF soldier Gilad Shalit in 2011 in exchange for 1,027 Palestinian prisoners, many guilty of multiple murders, among them Hamas leader and Oct. 7 mastermind Yahya Sinwar. “Never mind that it led to the capture of hundreds of more hostages. It doesn’t matter. We only see the individual pain right now. That’s the ideology,” Feiglin said.
Regarding the dangers the protests pose to the war effort, Feiglin offered a surprising answer. He said that Israel wasn’t heading towards a decisive victory to begin with. While the goals set out by Netanyahu sound good — destroying Hamas, releasing the hostages, and ensuring that Gaza never again constitutes a threat to the State of Israel — Feiglin insisted that “we lost the war before we started when we decided that the goal of the war was to eliminate Hamas.”